自动驾驶汽车测试场景构建关键技术综述

doi:10.19562/j.chinasae.qcgc.2021.04.019

Abstract

Abstract:

For autonomous vehicle test scenarios construction， this paper firstly makes a comparative analysis of the existing scenario definition and architecture， and proposes that test scenarios should cover a total of 10 layers of information of scene elements and test elements. Secondly， a method system of scenario construction including direct construction of concrete scenario， mining and deduction of typical logical scenario and reconstruction and derivation of specific scenario is summarized and proposed. Thirdly， from the three dimensions of single segment test， combined segment test and integrated traffic flow test， the main virtual scenario test application methods are systematically sorted out. Finally， the research prospect is presented from the perspective of method chain and tool chain of scenario construction. The research results of the review will provide reference for the testing and evaluation of autonomous vehicles.

Key words: autonomous vehicles, safety testing, scenario construction, review

Xiangyang Xu,Wenhao Hu,Honglei Dong,Yan Wang,Lingyun Xiao,Penghui Li. Review of Key Technologies for Autonomous Vehicle Test Scenario Construction[J].Automotive Engineering, 2021, 43(4): 610-619.

Figures/Tables 4

References 77

1	LIERSCH C. Automated vehicles supporting “Towards Zero” iniative ［J］. Journal of the Australasian College of Road Safety， 2017， 28（1）， 49-53.
2	DIXIT V V， SAI C， NAIR D J， et al. Autonomous vehicles： disengagements， accidents and reaction times ［J］. PLOS ONE， 2016， 11（12）： e0168054.
3	Taxonomy and definitions for terms related to driving automation systems for on⁃road motor vehicles： SAE J3016 ［S］.2018.
4	WINNER H. ADAS， Quo Vadis？［M］. Springer， Cham， 2016.
5	RÖSENERCHRISTIAN， FAHRENKROG F， UHLIG A， et al. A scenario⁃based assessment approach for automated driving by using time series classification of human⁃driving behavior ［C］. International Conference on Intelligent Transportation Systems （ITSC）. IEEE， 2016.
6	NHTSA. National statistics ［R］. America： NHTSA， 2019.
7	KALRA N， PADDOCK S M. Driving to safety： how many miles of driving would it take to demonstrate autonomous vehicle reliability？［J］. Transportation Research Part A： Policy & Practice， 2016， 94：182-193.
8	耿新力. 城区不确定环境下无人驾驶车辆行为决策方法研究［D］. 合肥：中国科学技术大学， 2017.
	GENG X L. Research on behavior decision⁃making approaches for autonomous vehicle in urban uncertainty environments ［D］. Hefei：University of Science and Technology of China， 2017.
9	GEYER S， BALTZER M， FRANZ B， et al. Concept and development of a unified ontology for generating test and use⁃case catalogues for assisted and automated vehicle guidance ［J］. IET Intelligent Transport Systems， 2013， 8（3）： 183-189.
10	GO K， CARROLL J M. The blind men and the elephant： views of scenario⁃based system design ［J］. Interactions， 2004， 11（6）： 44-53.
11	NAJM WASSIM G， BASAV SEN. Analysis of light vehicle crashes and pre⁃crash scenarios based on the 2000 general estimates system ［R］. America： NHTSA， 2003.
12	NAJM W G. Development of crash imminent test scenarios for integrated vehicle⁃based safety systems ［C］. International Technical Conference on Enhanced Safety of Vehicles. 2007.
13	BÁLINT， ANDRÁS， FAGERLIND H， et al. A test⁃based method for the assessment of pre⁃crash warning and braking systems ［J］. Accident Analysis & Prevention， 2013， 59：192-199.
14	NAJM W G. Description of light⁃vehicle pre⁃crash scenarios for safety applications based on vehicle⁃to⁃vehicle communications［R］. America： NHTSA， 2013.
15	ULBRICH S， MENZEL T， RESCHKA A， et al. Defining and substantiating the terms scene， situation， and scenario for automated driving ［C］. IEEE International Conference on Intelligent Transportation Systems. IEEE， 2015： 982-988.
16	WALTHER W， PHILIPP J， et al. Test case variation and execution ［R］. Germany： PEGASUS， 2019.
17	WALTHER W， PHILIPP J， et al. Scenario description ［R］. Germany： PEGASUS， 2019.
18	MENZEL T， BAGSCHIK G， MAURER M. Scenarios for development， test and validation of automated vehicles ［C］. 2018 IEEE Intelligent Vehicles Symposium （IV）. IEEE， 2018.
19	赵祥模，陈南峰，承靖钧，等. 基于整车在环仿真的自动驾驶汽车室内快速测试平台［J］. 中国公路学报， 2019， 32（6）：124-136.
	ZHAO X M， CHEN N F， CHENG J J， et al. An indoor rapid⁃testing platform for autonomous vehicle based on vehicle⁃in⁃the⁃loop simulation［J］. China Journal of Highway and Transport， 2019， 32（6）：124-136.
20	朱冰，张培兴，赵健，等. 基于场景的自动驾驶汽车虚拟测试研究进展［J］. 中国公路学报， 2019， 32（6）： 1-19.
	ZHU B， ZHANG P， ZHAO J， et al. Review of scenario⁃based virtual validation methods for automated vehicles［J］. China Journal of Highway and Transport， 2019， 32（6）：1-19.
21	National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. A framework for automated driving system testable cases and scenarios［R］. Virginia Tech Transportation Institute， Blacksburg， DOT HS812623. 2018.
22	舒红，袁康，修海林，等. 自动驾驶汽车基础测试场景构建研究［J］. 中国公路学报， 2019， 32（11）： 245-254.
	SHU H， YUAN K， XIU H L， et al. Construction of basic test scenarios of automated vehicles［J］. China Journal of Highway and Transport， 2019， 32（11）： 245-254.
23	陈名扬.自动驾驶研究在自动驾驶汽车开发中的应用［D］.上海：同济大学，2017.
	CHEN M Y. Application of naturalistic driving study in development of automated vehicles ［D］. Shanghai：Tongji University， 2017.
24	吴斌，朱西产，沈剑平，等. 基于自然驾驶数据的危险评估算法研究［J］. 汽车工程， 2017，39（8）：62-69.
	WU B， ZHU X C， SHEN J P， et al. A study on risk assessment algorithm based on natural driving data ［J］. Automotive Engineering， 2017，39（8）：62-69.
25	SUN X Y， ZHU X C， ZHANG K Y， et al. Automatic detection method research of incidents in China⁃FOT database［C］. International Conference on Intelligent Transportation Systems， 2016： 754-759.
26	WANG X， XU L H， SUN H B， et al. On-road vehicle detection and tracking using mmw radar and monovision fusion［J］. IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Transportation Systems， 2016， 17（7）：2075-2084.
27	ZHANG X， XU W D， DONG C Y， et al. Efficient L⁃shape fitting for vehicle detection using laser scanners［C］. 2017 IEEE Intelligent Vehicles Symposium （IV）. IEEE， 2017.
28	李英勃，于波. 基于融合感知的场景数据提取技术研究［J］. 现代计算机， 2019（9）：67-72.
	LI Y B， YU B. Research on drive scenario extract technique based on sensors fusion［J］. Modern Computer， 2019（9）：67-72.
29	袁泉，李一兵. 车辆碰撞事故再现技术研究的现状与发展方向［J］. 公路交通科技， 2002， 19（2）：122-125，130.
	YUAN Q， LI Y B. Review and trend of the technology of vehicle crash reconstruction［J］. Journal of Highway and Transportation Research and Development， 2002， 19（2）：122-125，130.
30	张雷，李一兵. 道路交通事故再现分析结果的不确定性分析［J］. 公路交通科技， 2007， 24（12）：140-143.
	ZHANG L， LI Y B. Analysis of traffic accident reconstruction uncertainty［J］. Journal of Highway and Transportation Research and Development， 2007， 24（12）：140-143.
31	邹铁方，胡林，李平凡，等. 一种分析事故再现仿真结果不确定性的多响应面-均匀设计法［J］. 汽车工程， 2017，39（1）：45-50，76.
	ZOU T F， HU L， LI P F， et al. A multi⁃response⁃surface uniform design method for analyzing uncertainty of simulation results in accident reconstruction ［J］. Automotive Engineering， 2017，39（1）：45-50，76.
32	袁泉，李一兵. 车辆交通事故再现能量方法的不确定度评定［J］. 中国公路学报， 2002， 15（1）：110-112.
	YUAN Q， LI Y B. Uncertainty evaluation on the energy method of vehicle traffic accident reconstruction ［J］. China Journal of Highway and Transport， 2002， 15（1）：110-112.
33	秦海力. 汽车碰撞事故再现与驾驶员损伤风险分析［D］. 重庆：重庆理工大学， 2018.
	QIN H L. Analysis of vehicle collision accident reconstruction and driver’s damage risk ［D］. Chongqing： Chongqing University of Technology， 2018.
34	机动车运行安全技术条件：［S］. 2017.
	Technical specifications for safety of power⁃driven vehicles operating on roads：［S］. 2017.
35	JONES W D. Black boxes get green light ［car crash data recorders］［J］. IEEE Spectrum， 2004， 41（12）：14-16.
36	邱金龙，李奎，苏森，等. 汽车事故数据记录器数据规范及应用进展综述［J］. 汽车工程学报， 2017， 7（2）：79-85.
	QIU J L， LI K， SU S， et al. Review on regulation and application progress of vehicle EDR data［J］. Chinese Journal of Automotive Engineering， 2017， 7（2）： 79-85.
37	电动汽车远程服务与管理系统技术规范第3部分：通信协议与数据格式：［S］. 2016.
	Technical specifications of remote service and management system for electric vehicles⁃Part 3： communication protocol and data format：［S］. 2016.
38	VUFO. PRE-CRASH-MATRIX （PCM） V5.0FORMAT ［EB/OL］. （2020-06-17）. .
39	WASSIM G N， JOHN D S， MIKIO Y. Pre⁃crash scenario typology for crash avoidance research ［R］. America： NHTSA， 2007.
40	NAJM W G， SMITH J D. Development of crash imminent test scenarios for integrated vehicle⁃based safety systems （IVBSS）［R］. America： NHTSA， 2007.
41	FAGERLIND H， HEINIG I， MATIAS V. Analysis of accident data for test scenario definition in the ASSESS project ［M］. Bundesanstalt für Straßenwesen （BASt）， 2010.
42	PHILIPPE N， PETE T， et al. Pre⁃crash scenarios at road junctions： a clustering method for car crash data ［J］. Accident Analysis and Prevention， 2017 （107）：137–151.
43	LENARD J， BADEA⁃ROMERO A， DANTON R. Typical pedestrian accident scenarios for the development of autonomous emergency braking test protocols ［J］. Accident Analysis and Prevention， 2014， 73（73）：73-80.
44	苏江平，陈君毅，王宏雁，等. 基于中国危险工况的行人交通冲突典型场景提取与分析［J］. 交通与运输（学术版）， 2017（1）：209-214.
	SU J P， CHEN J Y， WANG H Y， et al. Establishment and analysis on typical road traffic near⁃crash scenarios related to pedestrian in China ［J］. Traffic & Transportation， 2017（1）：209-214.
45	刘颖，贺锦鹏，刘卫国，等. 自动紧急制动系统行人测试场景的研究［J］. 汽车技术， 2014（3）：35-39.
	LIU Y， HE J P， LIU W G， et al. Research on test scenarios for aeb pedestrian system ［J］. Automobile Technology， 2014（3）：35-39.
46	胡林，易平，黄晶，等.基于真实事故案例的自动紧急制动系统两轮车测试场景研究［J］.汽车工程，2018，40（12）：1435-1446.
	HU L， YI P，HUANG J， et al. A research on test scenes of two⁃wheeled vehicles for automatic emergency braking system based on real accident cases ［J］. Automotive Engineering， 2018， 40（12）：1435-1446.
47	CAO Y， XIAO L Y， DONG H L， et al. Typical pre⁃crash scenarios reconstruction for two⁃wheelers and passenger vehicles and its application in parameter optimization of AEB system based on NAIS database. ［C］. Proceedings of the 26th International Technical Conference on the Enhanced Safety of Vehicles （ESV），2019.
48	SUI B， LUBBE N， BARGMAN J， et al. A clustering approach to developing car⁃to⁃two⁃wheeler test scenarios for the assessment of automated emergency braking in china using in⁃depth Chinese crash data［J］. Accident Analysis & Prevention， 2019， 132： 105242.
49	Road vehicles⁃safety of the intended functionality： ISO/PAS 2144
	82019 ［S］. 2019.
50	SARKER A， SHEN H， RAHMAN M， et al. A review of sensing and communication， human factors， and controller aspects for information⁃aware connected and automated vehicles ［J］. IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Transportation Systems， 2019：1-23.
51	ROSIQUE F， NAVARRO P J， FERNÁNDEZ， et al. A systematic review of perception system and simulators for autonomous vehicles research［J］. Sensors， 2019， 19（3）.
52	FOR W K， LEMAN K， ENG H L， et al. A multi⁃camera collaboration framework for real⁃time vehicle detection and license plate recognition on highways ［C］. Intelligent Vehicles Symposium. IEEE， 2008.
53	KIM J， HONG S， BAEK J， et al. Autonomous vehicle detection system using visible and infrared camera ［C］. International Conference on Control. IEEE， 2012.
54	STROHM K M， BLOECHER H L， SCHNEIDER R， et al. Development of future short range radar technology ［C］. European Radar Conference， 2005.
55	VANLEEUWEN M B， GROEN F C A. Vehicle detection with a mobile camera： spotting midrange， distant， and passing cars ［J］. IEEE Robotics & Automation Magazine， 2005， 12（1）：37-43.
56	THORNTON D A， REDMILL K， COIFMAN B. Automated parking surveys from a LIDAR equipped vehicle ［J］. Transportation Research Part C： Emerging Technologies， 2014， 39：23-35.
57	LIERS H. Analysis of the accident scenario of powered two⁃wheelers on the basis of real⁃world accidents［M］. Bundesanstalt für Straßenwesen （BASt）， 2013.
58	BOSCH. Predictive road⁃condition services ［R］. Germany： BOSCH， 2018.
59	BECHTLOFF J， ISERMANN R. A redundant sensor system with driving dynamic models for automated driving ［J］. Internationales Stuttgarter Symposiumpp， 2015：755-774.
60	方芳. 几种常见车路协同通信技术的比较研究［C］. 第十一届中国智能交通年会大会论文集，2016：1028-1033.
	FANG F. Research of cooperative vehicle⁃infrastructure communication technology［C］. Proceedings of the 11th China Intelligent Transportation Conference， 2016：1028-1033.
61	李克强，戴一凡，李升波，等.智能网联汽车（ICV）技术的发展现状及趋势［J］.汽车安全与节能学报，2017，8（1）：1-14.
	LI K Q， DAI Y F， LI S B， et al. State⁃of⁃the⁃art and technical trends of intelligent and connected vehicles［J］. Automotive Safety and Energy，2017，8（1）：1-14.
62	张伟，田丽萍，梁玉，等. 面向车联网多点协作联合传输的安全认证与密钥更新方法［J］. 中国公路学报， 2019， 32（6）：308-318.
	ZHANG W， TIAN L P， LIANG Y， et al. Key management scheme to secure coordinated multi⁃point joint transmission for vehicular networks［J］. China Journal of Highway and Transport， 2019， 32（6）：308-318.
63	WANG L B，王含笑，赵千，等.智能路面发展与展望［J］.中国公路学报，2019，32（4）：50-72.
	WANG L B， WANG H X， ZHAO Q， et al. Development and prospect of intelligent pavement［J］. China Journal of Highway and Transport， 2019，32（4）：50-72.
64	陈山枝，胡金玲，时岩，等. LTE-V2X车联网技术、标准与应用［J］. 电信科学， 2018， 34（4）：1-11.
	CHEN S Z， HU J L， SHI Y， et al. Technologies， standards and applications of LTE⁃V2X for vehicular networks［J］. Telecommunications Science， 2018， 34（4）：1-11.
65	SCHULDT F ， RESCHKA A ， MAURER M. A method for an efficient， systematic test case generation for advanced driver assistance systems in virtual environments［M］. Springer， Cham， 2018.
66	FELLNER A， KRENN W， SCHLICK R， et al. Model⁃based， mutation⁃driven test⁃case generation via heuristic⁃guided branching search［J］. Acm Transactions on Embedded Computing Systems， 2019， 18（1）：1-28.
67	XIA Q， DUAN J， GAO F， et al. Automatic generation method of test scenario for ADAS based on complexity［C］. SAE International， 2017.
68	ZHAO D， LAM H， PENG H， et al. Accelerated evaluation of automated vehicles safety in lane⁃change scenarios based on importance sampling techniques［J］. IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Transportation Systems， 2016：1-13.
69	HUANG Z， ZHAO D， LAM H， et al. Evaluation of automated vehicles in the frontal cut⁃in scenario⁃an enhanced approach using piecewise mixture models［C］. IEEE International Conference on Robotics & Automation， 2017.
70	ZHAO D， PENG H， BAO S， et al. Accelerated evaluation of automated vehicles using extracted naturalistic driving data［C］. The Dynamics of Vehicles on Roads and Tracks⁃Proceedings of the 24th Symposium of the International Association for Vehicle System Dynamics， 2015.
71	ZHAO D， HUANG X， PENG H， et al. Accelerated evaluation of automated vehicles in car⁃following maneuvers［J］. IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Transportation Systems， 2017：1-12.
72	HUANG Z， LAM H， LEBLANC D J， et al. Accelerated evaluation of automated vehicles using piecewise mixture models［J］. IEEE Transactions on Intelligent Transportation Systems， 2017：1-11.
73	HUANG Z， LAM H， ZHAO D， et al. An accelerated testing approach for automated vehicles with background traffic described by joint distributions［J］. International Conference on Intelligent Transportation Systems， 2017： 933-938.
74	成波，孔凡忠，等. 中国自动驾驶仿真技术研究报告（2019）［R］. 当家移动绿色互联网技术集团有限公司（51VR）， 2019.
	CHENG B， KONG F Z， et al. Annual research report on autonomous vehicle simulation in China （2019）［R］. 51 WORLD， 2019.
75	冯屹，王兆，等. 自动驾驶测试场景技术发展与应用［M］. 北京：机械工业出版社， 2020：110-113.
	FENG Y， WANG Z， et al. Development and application of automated⁃driving test scenario technology［M］. Beijing： China Machine Press， 2020：110-113.
76	腾讯云. 腾讯TAD Sim仿真平台，助力破解自动驾驶落地困境［EB/OL］. （2019-11-13）. .
	CloudTencent. Tencent TAD Sim simulation platform helps to solve the landing dilemma of automated driving ［EB/OL］. （2019-11-13）. .
77	ISO. STANDARES BY ISO//TC 22/SC 33 ［EB/OL］. （2020-06-17）. .

[1]	SHEN Zhe, WANG Yi-Gang, YANG Zhi-Gang, LI Fang-Xu. [J]. , 2016, 38(12): 1440 -1445 .
[2]	ZENG Bi-Qiang, GAO Ji-Dong, PENG Wei, SUN Zhen-Dong. [J]. , 2016, 38(12): 1446 -1451 .
[3]	LIU Hui, WANG Xiao-Jie, XIANG Chang-Le. [J]. , 2016, 38(12): 1483 -1487 .
[4]	CHEN Wu-Wei, DENG Shu-Chao, HUANG He, XIE You-Hao. [J]. , 2016, 38(12): 1488 -1493 .
[5]	PENG Qian-Lei, GUI Liang-Jin, FAN Zi-Jie. [J]. , 2016, 38(12): 1500 -1507 .
[6]	DONG Zhu-Rong, ZHANG Xin, HU Song-Hua, QIU Hao. [J]. , 2017, 39(1): 79 -85 .
[7]	SHI Hai-Min, YU Xiao-Li, LU Guo-Dong, HUANG Yu-Qi, LIU Zhen-Tao, HUANG Rui. [J]. , 2017, 39(1): 102 -106 .
[8]	QIN Chao-Ju, YANG Zhen-Zhong, ZHANG Wei-Zheng, SONG Li-Ye, YUAN Yan-Peng. [J]. , 2017, 39(2): 133 -137 .
[9]	ZHANG Guan-Jun, ZHAO Xin-Feng, CAO Li-Bo. [J]. , 2017, 39(2): 150 -158 .
[10]	CAO Li-Bo, HU Yuan, YAN Ling-Bo, PENG Yu, SHI Xiang-南. [J]. , 2017, 39(2): 174 -180 .

[1]	Xinke Fu,Yingfeng Cai,Long Chen,Hai Wang,Qingchao Liu. Decision-Making for Autonomous Driving in Uncertain Environment [J]. Automotive Engineering, 2024, 46(2): 211-221.
[2]	Cheng Lin, Bowen Wang, Lü Peiyuan, Xinle Gong, Xiao Yu. Research on Motion Planning and Cooperative Control for Autonomous Vehicles with Lane Change Gaming Maneuvers Under the Curved Road [J]. Automotive Engineering, 2023, 45(7): 1099-1111.
[3]	Jianhua Chen,Zhongming Xu,Zhifei Zhang. Suspension State Estimation Based on Wheelbase Preview at Variable Speed [J]. Automotive Engineering, 2023, 45(6): 1040-1049.
[4]	Yilin He,Jian Ma,Shukai Yang,Wei Zheng,Qifan Xue. Research on Stability Model Predictive Control of Intelligent Electric Vehicle with Preview Characteristics [J]. Automotive Engineering, 2023, 45(5): 719-734.
[5]	Zixian Li,Shiju Pan,Yuan Zhu,Binbing He,Youchun Xu. Semi-active Suspension Control for Intelligent Vehicles Based on State Feedback and Preview Feedforward [J]. Automotive Engineering, 2023, 45(5): 735-745.
[6]	Yanyan Chen,Hai Wang,Yingfeng Cai,Long Chen,Yicheng Li. Efficient Automatic Driving Instance Segmentation Method Based on Detection [J]. Automotive Engineering, 2023, 45(4): 541-550.
[7]	Lü Ying,Xu Qi,Qiuzheng Liu,Xinyu Wang,Guoying Chen. Path Tracking Control Method with Steering Lag for Autonomous Vehicles [J]. Automotive Engineering, 2023, 45(12): 2234-2241.
[8]	Zhengfa Liu,Ya Wu,Peigen Liu,Rongqi Gu,Guang Chen. Cross-Domain Object Detection for Intelligent Driving Based on Joint Distribution Matching of Features and Labels [J]. Automotive Engineering, 2023, 45(11): 2082-2091.
[9]	Long Chen,Chen Yang,Yingfeng Cai,Hai Wang,Yicheng Li. Pedestrian Crossing Intention Prediction Method Based on Multimodal Feature Fusion [J]. Automotive Engineering, 2023, 45(10): 1779-1790.
[10]	Fengchong Lan,Yingjie Liu,Jiqing Chen,Zhaolin Liu. Study on Motion Planning of Autonomous Vehicles in Cut-in Scenes Based on Dynamic Game Algorithm [J]. Automotive Engineering, 2023, 45(1): 9-19.
[11]	Yingshi Guo,Yahui Hu,Rui Fu,Chang Wang. Research on Driver Lateral Control Model Under Crosswind Conditions Based on Cognitive-Control Framework [J]. Automotive Engineering, 2022, 44(8): 1251-1261.
[12]	Yingfeng Cai,Ziheng Lu,Yicheng Li,Long Chen,Hai Wang. Tightly Coupled SLAM System Based on Multi-Sensor Fusion [J]. Automotive Engineering, 2022, 44(3): 350-361.
[13]	Jingwei Zhang,Tiejun Liu,Rengang Li,Dan Liu,Jinglin Zhan,Hongwei Kan. A Temporal Calibration Method for Multi-Sensor Fusion of Autonomous Vehicles [J]. Automotive Engineering, 2022, 44(2): 215-224.
[14]	Chaoyang Jiang,Tianran Lan,Xiaoni Zheng,Jiulong Gao,Xuetong Ye. Distributed Multi-vehicle Collaborative Visual SLAM System [J]. Automotive Engineering, 2022, 44(12): 1809-1817.
[15]	Yuande Jiang,Bing Zhu,Xiangmo Zhao,Jian Zhao,Bingbing Zheng. Modeling of Traffic Vehicle Interaction for Autonomous Vehicle Testing [J]. Automotive Engineering, 2022, 44(12): 1825-1833.

Review of Key Technologies for Autonomous Vehicle Test Scenario Construction

RichHTML

PDF (PC)

Like

Knowledge

Abstract

Cite this article

share this article

Figures/Tables 4

References 77

Related Articles 15

Metrics

Comments

Recommended 10